Monday, March 26, 2012

classical conditioning and placebo effects

Classical conditioning is a form of learning or physiological change. It is based on forming an association between a stimulus and a response. The association is remembered and affects future similar experiences. Some physiological responses to stimuli are unconditioned: they happen naturally and involuntarily, like blinking, flinching, or the salivation response to the taste or odor of food. Other physiological responses are conditioned: for example, a dog can be conditioned to salivate when a bell is rung because the dog has been taught to associate the bell with food (Pavlov's famous experiment). Dogs injected with morphine begin to salivate and can be conditioned to salivate from any injection, whether with morphine or not.

Relief from pain is often attributed to the placebo effect when no active pain-killer has been administered and the patient reports that the pain has lessened. A more accurate description in some such cases, however, might be that the patient has learned to associate pain reduction with pushing a button that releases morphine or with getting a morphine injection. I know from experience that self-monitored morphine injection devices are designed to prevent an unsafe amount of morphine from being taken. The patient may push the button and feel relief but after a certain amount of morphine has been released, pushing the button does not release morphine despite what the patient might think. People who have been injected with saline solution but think they are getting morphine may feel relief from pain because they are conditioned to expect relief after the injection.

Conditioning and associative learning--along with owner or practitioner expectation and self-deception--might explain why some animals appear to get relief from reiki, homeopathy, or acupuncture. A woman who does reiki on horses wrote me: "Animals have no preconceived ideas about Reiki; no expectations about a treatment. There is no placebo effect with animals." Those who think animals can't respond to placebos should consider that what is sometimes called the placebo effect is actually a conditioned response to a stimulus and it is a well-known fact that animals respond to conditioning. Conditioning does not have to be done consciously, nor does it have to involve acts like clapping or ringing a bell. Nor does it have to involve belief. The rituals a vet or pet owner goes through with an animal when it is injured or ill can have a conditioning effect.

Conditioning can involve much more than obvious factors like getting an injection, taking a pill, or being touched where it hurts. Conditioning can involve the theater of the medical setting and medical rituals, including the medical uniforms worn, medical jargon spoken, and medical gadgetry used. These conditions affect the patient's expectation of relief from the treatment, as does the manner of the healer. Patient expectation, it turns out, plays a significant role in the effectiveness of many kinds of treatment. Classical conditioning is "hypothesized to be the primary triggering mechanism for the placebo effect ... which must be learned before it can manifest itself...." (Bausell 2007: 131). When conditioning is combined with desire and motivation for relief, the placebo effect is boosted for both active and inert substances.

A common misunderstanding regarding placebos is that a placebo must be an inert substance that tricks the patient into thinking he's been given an active substance. Many people think that the placebo effect is "all in the head," but that is no more true than that people's physiological and behavioral responses to what they think is alcohol or a drug are only in their head. People can be conditioned to respond physiologically and behaviorally "to placebos through repeated administrations of active drugs" (Bausell 2007: 132) and to hypnosis through learned expectation.

Antonella Pollo et al. demonstrated that placebos can help people with serious pain and Martina Amanzio et al. (2001) demonstrated that "at least part of the physiological basis for the placebo effect is opioid in nature." That is, we can be conditioned to release such chemical substances as endorphins, catecholamines, cortisol, and adrenaline. One reason, perhaps, that people report pain relief from both acupuncture and sham acupuncture is that both are placebos that stimulate the opioid system.

Donald D. Price, an expert on pain, has demonstrated that conditioning and expectation significantly affect the experience of pain and pain reduction. R. Barker Bausell speculates that since complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) practitioners' greatest asset is their nourishment of hope, "such therapies may be engendering nothing more than the expectation that they will reduce pain by elaborate explanations, promises, and ceremonies" (2007: 149). He also notes that the analgesics prescribed by our physicians receive a boost in efficacy based on our past experience and expectations. Many advocates of energy medicine mistake the effects of classical conditioning, expectation of relief that leads to reduction of anxiety and stress, and beliefs about the effectiveness of energy medicine as being consequences of manipulating a mythical subtle energy.

In her book, Women Aren't Supposed to Fly: The Memoirs of a Female Flight Surgeon, Dr. Harriet Hall tells the story of a vasectomy patient who underwent the surgery without anesthesia because he was mistakenly injected with saline solution rather than lidocaine. She also tells the story of a woman whose severe headaches went away after being injected with saline. The latter swore that only Demerol worked for her, but she had been conditioned to feel relief when she got a shot.

So, the next time you are wondering how healers can cure people with a simple touch or by waving their hands in the air over a body part or by uttering some ineffable incantation, think that maybe, just maybe, some sort of conditioned response is going on. You don't have to call it a placebo response, but if you do, don't assume that classical conditioning is the only explanation for placebo effects. There may be other explanations for some placebo responses and the issue may be more complicated than you think. It is unlikely that the "healer" unblocked chi, evoked the assistance of a supernatural being, transferred her animal magnetism, unleashed a vital force in the memory of water, or erased memories of pain by tapping your tummy. Remember the old saying: when you hear hoof beats, think horses not zebras. Well, when you hear of magical healing, think classical conditioning, natural regression, misdiagnosis, symptom fluctuation, patient politeness and subordination, or a host of other things. Your first inclination might be to think magic or miracle, but first inclinations may be responses to the availability bias. If it's truth you're after, you might want to consider alternative explanations to what your intuition tells you.

24 comments:

  1. Tell your stylist if you have had any recent surgery, including cosmetic or reconstructive surgery. australia

    ReplyDelete
  2. It seems almost all and sundry who has net savvy has their very own weblog. It might be about their very very own lives, their studies or a product, service, facts or opinion. want-to-be writers write novels and quick testimonies. Gmod game

    ReplyDelete
  3. If you need to select a blogging platform to create a new blog, you will be able to choose from numerous options. Different types of bloggers are able to avail varying benefits from each of these platforms, but if you are a beginner, then the right the Blogger platform is the right blogging platform for you. You might be curious why Blogger is appropriate for you.Casual Shoes men

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hey what a superexcellent post i've stumble upon and consider me i've been seeking out for this similar form of submit for past per week and hardly ever came across this. thanks very a lot and will search for greater postings from you.  Visit Here

    ReplyDelete
  5. Your blog postings are going well but it is getting more and more difficult to come up with new topics about which to write. After reading this article, coming up with blog topics will no longer be an issue.webcam models jobs

    ReplyDelete
  6. Oh how I wish I could be there -these look fabulous! a dipsomaniac ghost is the best kind to have, I would think.real estate mississauga

    ReplyDelete
  7. Many of the Online Jobs and Online Earning System in internet online Business, but here is a best and legit online earning systems with life time opportunity.B & B on the Tuscan sea 2 stars

    ReplyDelete
  8. I found your this post while searching for some related information on blog search...Its a good post..keep posting and update the information.zľavy sme

    ReplyDelete
  9. An individual's lash as well as migrate are typically altered as well as improved effective to the phantasm ruby near the scholarship. pensioni viareggio 1 stella

    ReplyDelete
  10. Valuable information. Fortunate me I found your web site accidentally, and I’m stunned why this twist of fate did not happened earlier! I bookmarked it.plays in peoria il

    ReplyDelete
  11. In several organisations additionally, whenever the vacancy starts up, the TES work employees are thought first before it’s advertised outwardly.rhinoplasty dallas

    ReplyDelete
  12. hat,s a great and interesting blog. I am feeling happy after read that blog.rent apartments panama

    ReplyDelete
  13. Shen Tong is a top serial entrepreneur and an angel investor. Shen Tong is the founding member of well-reputed organizations like Food-X and FoodFutureCo. Shen Tong has invested in multiple companies which works towards good food and sustainable agriculture. Shen Tong has been supporting numerous organizations not only with funding but also with advice whenever needed. Shen Tong believes that health is efficient, so he is in support of not introducing digital efficiency into a traditional industry or market. According to Shen Tong, “our brain does not need to be tracked when it comes to food. Real food is naturally satisfying. So nature is our friend. That's the real friend here, and so this is one movement that Shen Tong joined and made a long-term commitment that he can have a smile on his face.” Shen Tong has invested in projects like GreenBlender, KitchenBowl, BoosterAgro, Servy and many more. Shen Tong not only invests money in a project he finds innovative but also pitches in advice and all the support he can to make the project a huge success.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Shen Tong


    Shen Tong
    Shen Tong
    Shen Tong
    Shen Tong
    Zhu Yu Pian StasisClear Removes Blood Stasis This Works,
    Shen Tong
    Shen Tong
    Shen Tong
    Shen Tong


    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rangtong-Shentong



    ReplyDelete
  15. Affordable Hamilton Dentist, Dr. Vinicio Aldana a leading professional dentist in Hamilton offers high quality best dental services at affordable prices ensuring you healthy smile.

    ReplyDelete

  16. A young billionaire who was ahead of his time and is now investing in brilliant minds like him. When everyone was busy playing and dreaming about they would want to be in the future, Evan Luthra was busy building himself and his curiousness for technology made him build an app at the age of 12. Before turning 15 he started building apps that were used by many big companies. Evan Luthra is a young millionaire who is changing the way the world sees technology.

    By the age of 18, he was speaking for TedX. Evan Luthra spoke at the United Nations, TEDx, Crypto Investor Show, Blockshow and more. He is an angel investor and also features in the 30 under 30 entrepreneurs list. Evan Luthra is now working on his entrepreneur venture of investing in ideas that are innovative, profitable and futuristic.

    Evan Conceptualizes, Innovates and then works on Executing world-changing ideas. Evan Luthra is COO and co-founder of El Group international or many big tech projects. Evan started his journey from building products and now is building brands. His venture Startup studio.online allows him to discover talents and futuristic ideas that he can support and take further.

    ReplyDelete
  17. thanks for share this
    Evan Luthra has that rare and coveted ability to turn original ideas into businesses that are both innovative and profitable. At 24 years-old, he has an already impressive resume and career history. A young billionaire who was ahead of his time and is now investing in brilliant minds like him. When everyone was busy playing and dreaming about they would want to be in the future, Evan Luthra was busy building himself and his curiousness for technology made him build an app at the age of 12. Before turning 15 he started building apps that were used by many big companies. Evan Luthra is a young millionaire who is changing the way the world sees technology. Evan Luthra started his journey as a serial entrepreneur as an adolescent and was bitten by the "digital bug" early and often. This forward thinking, technology-minded entrepreneur embarked on his first digital endeavor at just twelve years old by curating technology-related news, and evan luthra garnered a 250,000 readers in doing so. Evan Luthra then began developing mobile apps with the advent of mobile app popularity. Always on the cusp and leading edge of new trends and innovations, Evan Luthra has become a true innovator and a recognized name in the world of Startups. Evan Luthra is now working on his entrepreneur venture of investing in ideas that are innovative, profitable and futuristic.
    Evan Luthra is also influencing the world through his social media handles. With over 500,000 followers he is always sharing bits of his life and words of wisdom to let the world know that Startup studio is there to listen to your extraordinary ideas

    ReplyDelete
  18. Evan Luthra is one of the youngest tycoons in the IT industry today and has invested in numerous tech projects to this date. Evan Luthra started giving TedX speeches at the age of 18 and since then, he has also spoken at some of the most prestigious events including Crpto Investor Show, Blockshow, etc. He has been featured in 30 under 30 entrepreneurs list and is known to support and guide budding entrepreneurs through his incubator Startup Studio.

    Having accumulated years of experience in the tech industry, Evan Luthra is today spearheading innovation in projects that are laying the foundation of our better future. He is not just a co-founder and COO of EL Group International, but he is also an active contributor in the global entrepreneurship community. Through Startup Studio, he is able to identify emerging businesses and share his business acumen that can drive these projects to success.

    Although Evan Luthra invests in all kinds of tech projects, he focuses on blockchain projects as that sphere has become more of his specialization. He was instrumental in the success of blockchain projects like Relictum Pro, Crescent, and Relictum Pro.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Thanks for sharing:
    Evan Luthra a young billionaire who was ahead of his time and is now investing in brilliant minds like him.Evan Luthra is one of the youngest tycoons in the IT industry today and has invested in numerous tech projects to this date. Evan Luthra started giving TedX speeches at the age of 18 and since then, he has also spoken at some of the most prestigious events including Crpto Investor Show, Blockshow, etc. He has been featured in 30 under 30 entrepreneurs list and is known to support and guide budding entrepreneurs through his incubator Startup Studio.

    Having accumulated years of experience in the tech industry, Evan Luthra is today spearheading innovation in projects that are laying the foundation of our better future. He is not just a co-founder and COO of EL Group International, but he is also an active contributor in the global entrepreneurship community. Through Startup Studio, he is able to identify emerging businesses and share his business acumen that can drive these projects to success.

    Although Evan Luthra invests in all kinds of tech projects, he focuses on blockchain projects as that sphere has become more of his specialization. He was instrumental in the success of blockchain projects like Relictum Pro, Crescent, and Relictum Pro.Evan Luthrais also influencing the world through his social media handles. With over 500,000 followers he is always sharing bits of his life and words of wisdom to let the world know that Evan Luthra is there to listen to your extraordinary ideas.

    ReplyDelete
  20. immigration law firm NJ providing legal services and representation to clients throughout the state and region. The firm’s practice areas encompass Corporate Law, family law, divorce, and DACA. Our experience enables us to provide the best solutions through creative ways and specific strategies tailored to your legal matter.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I was diagnosed as HEPATITIS B carrier in 2013 with fibrosis of the
    liver already present. I started on antiviral medications which
    reduced the viral load initially. After a couple of years the virus
    became resistant. I started on HEPATITIS B Herbal treatment from
    ULTIMATE LIFE CLINIC (www.ultimatelifeclinic.com) in March, 2020. Their
    treatment totally reversed the virus. I did another blood test after
    the 6 months long treatment and tested negative to the virus. Amazing
    treatment! This treatment is a breakthrough for all HBV carriers.

    ReplyDelete