Monday, August 13, 2012

regressive fallacy

The regressive fallacy is an error in causal reasoning: the failure to take into account natural and inevitable fluctuations when ascribing causes to events (Gilovich 1993: 26). Golf scores and chronic back pain, for example, inevitably fluctuate. Periods of low scores or little or no pain are eventually followed by periods of higher scores or more intense pain. Ignoring natural fluctuations can easily lead to the availability bias driving one to confirm a favored causal explanation based on little more than that one thing happened after the other (the post hoc fallacy).

A professional golfer with chronic back pain or arthritis, for example, might try a copper bracelet on his wrist or magnetic insoles in his shoes when he is not playing or feeling well. He notices that his scores are improving and his pain is diminishing or gone. He concludes that the copper bracelet or the magnetic insole is the cause of his feeling and playing better. He doesn't consider that the scores and the pain are probably improving due to natural and expected fluctuations. Nor does it occur to him that he could check a record of all his golf scores to see what kind of fluctuation in scoring has occurred in the past. If he takes his average score as a base, most likely he would find that after a very low score he tended to shoot not a lower score but a higher score in the direction of his average. Likewise, he would find that after a very high score, he did not tend to shoot another higher score but rather would shoot a lower score in the direction of his average. In fact, overall it is inevitable that a golfer's scores tend toward the average.

This tendency to move toward the average away from extremes was called "regression" by Sir Francis Galton (1822-1911) in a study of the average heights of sons of very tall and very short parents. (The study was published in 1885 and was called "Regression Toward Mediocrity in Hereditary Stature.") He found that sons of very tall or very short parents tend to be tall or short, respectively, but not as tall or as short as their parents. On reflection, Galton's discovery seems like common sense: it seems obvious that children can't get taller or shorter ad infinitum.

Many people are led to believe in the causal efficacy of questionable therapies and treatments because of the regressive fallacy. The intensity and duration of an illness or of pain from arthritis, chronic backache, gout, etc., fluctuate. A remedy such as acupuncture, a chiropractic spinal manipulation, a homeopathic potion, or a magnetic belt is likely to be sought when the illness or pain is at its worst. The illness or pain in most cases would begin to lessen after it has peaked. It is easy to deceive ourselves into thinking that the remedy we sought caused our reduction in suffering. It is because of the ease with which we can deceive ourselves about causality in such matters that scientists do controlled experiments to test causal claims. Such experiments reduce the chances of self-deception and confirmation bias that inevitably accompany personal experience.


  1. People do not like being told this. It destroys their dreams (their golf scores will continue to improve) and hope that their pain will go away. Skeptics have to find ways to challenge people without knocking the chair out from under them.
    How can the fallacy be adjusted so the person delivering the 'bad' news isn't seen as being bad and the lessons learned will be beneficial.
    Brian Iverson

    1. Recently, a business associate shared with me an intriguing story about someone with back pain...

      Michelle Onoff is a successful yoga instructor. Yet for some reason, she suffered with lower back pain.

      As a chiropractor, and someone in the healthcare field, I was fascinated by this.

      I don't know about you, but I was under the impression that yoga instructors, given their active, stretch-filled, muscle-focused, posture-perfect profession and lifestyle, would be the LAST PEOPLE ON EARTH to experience back pain.

      Actually, I was kind of shocked.

      If a health-minded yoga instructor can be dealt a crippling back pain blow, what does this say about the rest of us?

      Here's Michelle story in her own words. I think it'll inspire hope if you're suffering...

      "I was feeling very weak in my core area. And I was having some radiating pain in my lower back.

      And I was going to the doctors, and they were telling me things like you need to have disc replacement.

      You need to have all these surgeries...

      You need to be on these pain medications;

      And they wanted to put me through a lot of surgical procedures...

      I didn’t want to do ANY of that. But the pain was so bad... I needed some relief.

      So I went to two neurosurgeons and I went to a back pain specialist...

      The surgeons wanted to operate on me in different places...

      … and the back pain specialist wanted to do various procedures, including implanting something permanent in my spine.

      I’ve had four procedures that involved needles in my spine, epidurals in my spine and that only gave me a little bit of temporary relief for a couple days.

      But it did not cure or really help anything.

      It just put a band-aid on a pain for couple of days and that was it.

      After my first session of Back Pain Relief4Life, I felt an opening in my back that I haven’t felt in a long time.

      I felt stronger to my core and I felt that that radiating burning heat pain that I was feeling, seem to dissipate a little bit.

      It seemed to just open up my back in general.

      And then after my second session today, I noticed EVEN MORE the stretch in my lower back and more strengthening in muscles that had been weak that I think might help support my lower back.

      I was VERY SKEPTICAL about doing Back Pain Relief4Life. Because, as I am a yoga instructor, I feel very knowledgeable in anatomy. And how to help people that come to me in pain.

      But I was not aware of certain muscles that I was not using in the body that might help my lower back."

      - Michelle Onoff

      Here's the back pain program she's referring to:

      ==>Back Pain Relief 4 Life

      I share this with you today because if you suffer from back pain (like 3/4 of the population), I'm told this pain relief program WORKS WONDERS.

      People, in as little as 16 minutes, have experienced nothing less than total relief. Do nothing more than a specific sequence of 8 simple, pain-relieving movements.

      Sounds incredible, but yet Michelle is a prime example.

      See for yourself. Especially if you're being told surgery, needles and medication are in your immediate future.

      ==>Back Pain Relief 4 Life

      You've got nothing to lose.

      Rajinder Singh

      PS: My personal takeaway? Michelle was humble to admit yoga wasn't working for her.

      To me? That takes guts.

      She was also smart enough to stay away from drugs and surgery when there were other more natural options.

      But sometimes, one gets to the point where you'll try ANYTHING to get even a little bit of relief. If you're at that point, I encourage you to check out:

      ==>Back Pain Relief 4 Life

  2. I don't think this post is up to your normal outstanding standard of posting. And I don't think this lapse represents an example of you regressing toward the mean.

    The problem is that the phenomenon of regression toward the mean is a mathematical quirk arising out of imperfect correlations. It is not a phenomenon that has explanatory value for changes in the lives of any particular individual. Regression to the mean is observed with data for subgroups found at either extreme end of a distribution of scores for a particular variable. Although some in the subgroup may be linked to an even more extreme score on the same variable measured at a different time or for another variable, most of those with the most extreme scores will tend to be relatively less extreme. Regression to the mean is a matter of tendency toward less extreme relative position not less extreme magnitude of scores in absolute terms.

  3. Nearly 30 years ago, when I was in my late 30s, I knew a man who suffered from arthritis and who wore a copper bracelet. He maintained that it made his arthritis much less bad. It occurred to me that prevention is better than cure, so I bought a copper bracelet for myself. It was very cheap. I wore it for about 15 years, until it broke. Somehow, I never got round to buying a replacement. I am now 66, and have no arthritis. True story, but exactly what can one extract from it?
    You might say that my use of the bracelet as a prophylactic was a brilliant decision, which has kept me free of arthritis up till now (and maybe not a second longer). Or you might say that I'm simply not the type that gets arthritis. Absence of arthritis (or anything else) is a negative condition, and nothing can ever be proved using negative conditions alone. Of course, if I came from a family which was very prone to arthritis (I don't), and if I was the only member who had used the bracelet AND the only one who had avoided the condition, it would seem intuitively likely that there was an association. In that case, one would search for a mechanism.
    Aho! Perhaps I should buy another bracelet. They probably cost a lot more now, maybe as much as a pub lunch and a couple of pints.

  4. I truly cherished reading your weblog. It turned into very well authored and smooth to recognize. not like different blogs i have read which can be simply no longer that right.thank you alot!free gmod addons

  5. Excellent website design come in many forms, it all depends on what your criteria is for the best web design. Pakistani shoes

    It is a very hard situation when playing the lottery and never won, or keep winning low fund not up to 100 bucks, i have been a victim of such a tough life, the biggest fund i have ever won was 100 bucks, and i have been playing lottery for almost 12 years now, things suddenly change the moment i came across a secret online, a testimony of a spell caster called dr emu, who help people in any type of lottery numbers, i was not easily convinced, but i decided to give try, now i am a proud lottery winner with the help of dr emu, i won $1,000.0000.00 and i am making this known to every one out there who have been trying all day to win the lottery, believe me this is the only way to win the lottery.

    Contact him on email
    What's app +2347012841542
    Website Https://

  7. My dad was diagnosed with Parkinson's disease his symptoms were shuffling of feet,slurred speech, low volume speech, degradation of hand writing, horrible driving skills, right arm held at 45 degree angle, but now he finally free from the disease with the help of total cure from ULTIMATE LIFE CLINIC, he now walks properly and all symptoms has reversed, he had trouble with balance especially at night, getting into the shower and exiting it is difficult,getting into bed is also another thing he finds impossible.we had to find a better solution for his condition which has really helped him a lot,the biggest helped we had was ultimate life clinic they walked us through the proper steps,am highly recommended this to anyone who needs help.